Smart Plugs vs. Smart Thermostats: Where to Actually Start

Smart home devices marketed for energy savings range from $15 plugs to $250 thermostats, and it's not always obvious which actually moves the needle on your bill. The short answer: for most homes, a smart thermostat saves more in absolute dollars, but smart plugs are cheaper to start with and target a real, if smaller, source of waste.

What smart thermostats actually save

Heating and cooling is typically the largest single category on a home energy bill, which is why even modest improvements in how a thermostat is managed can add up. A smart thermostat's main savings mechanism is automated setbacks — reducing heating or cooling when you're away or asleep — done more consistently than most people manage manually, plus learning features that adjust the schedule based on actual occupancy patterns over time.

ENERGY STAR-certified smart thermostats are estimated to save a meaningful share of a typical home's heating and cooling costs, though actual savings vary significantly based on your climate, your home's insulation, and how much setback your previous thermostat habits already captured.

What smart plugs actually save

Smart plugs target standby or "phantom" load — power drawn by devices that are plugged in but not actively in use, like a TV in standby mode, a game console, or chargers left plugged in. Individually these draws are small, often just a few watts each, but across a household with many devices they add up to a noticeable, if modest, chunk of a typical electric bill.

Smart plugs let you schedule or remotely cut power to these devices entirely rather than leaving them in standby, and are also useful for things like ensuring lights or appliances aren't accidentally left running.

Where to start on a budget

If you're choosing one first purchase, a smart thermostat is generally the better return per dollar spent, because heating and cooling represents a larger share of most bills than standby power from electronics — the "biggest lever" tends to beat the "cheapest lever" in absolute savings.

That said, smart plugs are a reasonable starting point if you rent (a thermostat swap may not be possible or worth it for a temporary living situation), if your existing thermostat is already fairly efficient, or simply if the lower upfront cost matters more right now.

A reasonable order to buy in

1. Smart thermostat — if you own your home and don't already have one, this is usually the single highest-impact device for most households.
2. Smart plugs for your highest-draw idle devices — a game console, a home entertainment center, or an office setup with multiple chargers are good targets before spreading plugs across low-draw devices.
3. Whole-home energy monitor (a further step up) — for households that want to see where energy is actually going room by room, rather than guessing.

FAQ

Do smart plugs work with any device? Most standard plug-in devices, yes — but they're not suitable for high-draw, hardwired appliances like ovens or central AC units, which need dedicated circuits rather than a standard outlet.

Is a smart thermostat worth it if I already set back my regular thermostat manually? The savings gap is smaller for someone already disciplined about manual setbacks, but a smart thermostat still typically adds value through more consistent scheduling, remote control, and, in many models, room-by-room sensors that a basic thermostat doesn't offer.

Do smart plugs require a hub, or do they connect directly to Wi-Fi? Most consumer smart plugs today connect directly to home Wi-Fi without a separate hub, though some ecosystems (particularly those built around Zigbee or Z-Wave) still use one — check the specific product before buying.

Found an error? See our Corrections Policy.